Shivangi Sinha
Directed by Monika Mitchell, the 2024 film ‘A Stranger’s Child’ explored the fragility of identity and the unsettling speed with which life can change. The story follows Donna Fendyr, who wakes up in a hospital with no memory of who she is. She is handed a baby said to be hers, yet she has no recollection of ever being pregnant or giving birth. Her confusion deepens when she sees news reports about a missing infant matching the same age as the child now in her arms. With no one she can fully trust, Donna embarks on a desperate search for the truth. The film explores themes of memory, trust, and maternal instinct, examining how they shape our sense of self and reality.
A Stranger’s Child Draws Attention to the Real-World Issue of Missing Children
‘A Stranger’s Child’ is not an easy film to sit through, as the uncertainty surrounding the protagonist casts doubt on both the narrative perspective and the reliability of the narrator. Penned by Helen Marsh, the screenplay is not drawn from any single true event or personal experience, but from a surreal atmosphere that repeatedly edges toward truth through its characters and the emotions they convey. Donna’s character, in particular, feels an unexplainable pull toward the child, a connection rooted less in logic and more in the emotional undercurrents that define the story’s world. These tenets pull the film into the real world and make for a story that resonates with all.
In the film, the pull Donna feels toward the child speaks of the emotional gravity of real-life cases of missing children, where uncertainty and hope intertwine. Such cases often capture global attention, not just for their tragedy, but for the unanswered questions they leave behind. One of the most infamous is the disappearance of Madeleine McCann in 2007, when the three-year-old vanished from a holiday apartment in Portugal. Despite extensive investigations and international media coverage, her whereabouts remain unknown. The parents were thoroughly investigated and the case was taken to the highest forums possible, but the child was never found. The film draws attention to such real events, which have sadly become common headlines.
The Phenomenon of Memory Loss is Not Unheard of in Real Life
Amnesia has often played a role in criminal investigations, with suspects or witnesses claiming memory loss to explain gaps in their accounts. In some cases, it raises questions about whether the memory loss is genuine or a deliberate attempt to evade responsibility. A notable example is Karin Ziolkowski. In November 2016, police in Waterbury, Connecticut, found her 8-year-old son, Elijah, dead from asphyxiation. Investigators also discovered that Ziolkowski had set fire to the home before fleeing. She was later arrested in North Carolina and extradited to Connecticut, where she faced charges of murder and arson. She claimed that she was suffering from amnesia and had no recollection of what transpired, but was ultimately convicted.
The film plays on the intertwined themes of amnesia and criminal investigation. Memory loss is not treated as a mere plot device, but as a lens to examine how truth can be obscured or reshaped by trauma. The protagonist’s fractured recollections mirror the viewer’s own uncertainty and build tension through subtle, unsettling clues that emerge over time. The film is fantastical at times, but it is its resonance with the real world in its fractured style that finds its truth. The human element in justice and criminal investigations truly comes to the forefront and challenges the audience to question their own perceptions.
Read More: Is Glass Heart Based on a True Story?
