Abhiroop Das
Created by Megan Gallagher, Peacock’s ‘All Her Fault‘ takes a peek into the mysterious Irvine family, whose lives go into complete disarray when five-year-old Milo Irvine is kidnapped. The investigations that follow end up revealing more about Milo’s parents, Marissa and Peter, than it does about the potential suspects. When Jenny, the mother of Milo’s best friend, finds herself trapped in the web of conspiracies, everything changes. In the season finale, Carrie, the kidnapper, reveals that she is Milo’s real mother, and Peter had swapped her baby with his and Marissa’s following a tragic road accident. In the chaos that follows, both Carrie and Peter meet their end, but Marissa and Jenny’s tales are far from over. Given that this psychological thriller series fully adapts the eponymous, standalone book by Andrea Mara, a continuation of the story is unlikely, but in the best-case scenario, fans can expect a season 2 sometime around 2027.
All Her Fault Season 2 Might Continue Marissa and Jenny’s Independent Journeys
While the ending of season 1 wraps up most of the plot points, the final moments end on a curious note, with both Marissa and Jenny sitting down for a long-overdue moment of relaxation, as their children play together. Given that both women have recently bid goodbye to their respective partners in one way or another, it is possible that a continuation of the story might see them take on new avenues on the professional and home front. For Marissa, the task at hand is to rebuild her company from scratch, as her business ally, Colin, is now dead. On the other hand, Jenny’s future is closely related to the success of Lee Logan’s next book, which will be published under the banner of Blackhorn agency. Both these plot threads make for dramatic beats and have a strong chance of taking center stage, alongside whichever new mystery is added to the mix.
While Marissa and Jenny make new strides in life, the trajectories of the rest of the characters, most notably Brian, Lia, and Detective Alcaras, are still largely in the dark. The latter’s story has the most pressing twists and turns, as in the final episode, he participates in witness tampering for a wealthy businessman to ensure that his son, Sam, gets into a prestigious school. Given the risks attached to this maneuver, it is possible that a potential sequel will look deeper into the officer’s crime, especially in conjunction with his off-the-books investigation into Peter’s murder and Milo’s parentage. The ending brings a string of sorrows for Brian and Lia, and with both Peter and Colin now dead, their future looks grimmer than ever. While the brief mention of possible treatments for Brian’s disability in the earlier episodes can potentially open the door to a better future for him, the same cannot be said for Lia with certainty, who might relapse into her drug addiction.
All Her Fault Season 2 Can Expect Some Major Departures in the Cast
Given the first season’s thrilling conclusion, the cast for a potential sequel is bound to see a major haul on several fronts. Still, the majority of the core cast is likely to continue their roles if the show is greenlit for a continuation, with actors Sarah Snook and Dakota Fanning returning to play Marissa and Jenny. Michael Peña, who essays Detective Alcaras, can be expected to have a prominent role in the future, given that many plot threads surrounding him are yet to reach their conclusion. While Daniel Monks and Abby Elliott, who play Lia and Brian Irvine respectively, are most likely to reprise their roles, the uncertainty of their futures leaves the room open for speculation. On the other hand, the return of child actors Duke McCloud and Tayden Jax Ryan in the roles of Milo Irvine and Jacob Kaminski, respectively, depends on what direction the show takes, as the age difference between the actors and their characters might play a part in the casting choice.
Season one also witnesses its fair share of death and mayhem, which means that several actors’ time with the show might have come to an end. The biggest names potentially landing in this list are Sophia Lillis and Jake Lacy, who play Carrie Finch and Peter Irvine, respectively. However, given the narrative significance of both these deaths, both on a plot and thematic level, it cannot be said for sure whether the actors are through with the show. A dream sequence or flashback is always on the cards, as the show has established those techniques as a part of its storytelling arsenal. The same holds true for Jayl Elis, who essays Colin Dobbs, Marissa’s business partner, who is killed in the finale. On the other hand, Thomas Cocquerel’s return to the show is uncertain, as his character, Richie, ends his marriage with Jenny and sets out on his path in the end.
All Her Fault Season 2 Might Further Explore the Characters’ Gray Sides
While ‘All Her Fault’ studies moral decay at its various stages, the inaugural season ends on an empowering note for Marissa and Jenny, paving the way for them to break free of patriarchal impositions. However, the elephant in the room continues to be Peter’s stealthy murder, and with Detective Alcaras still on this trail, it is only a matter of time before Marissa gives him the ammunition he needs. This directly brings Milo’s future into the forefront, as well as the promise his mother made to Carrie. To that end, a potential season 2 can take the shape of Marissa versus Alcaras, with another round of secrets from both families intensifying the battle further. For Jenny, who is on the cusp of carving her name into the publishing industry, the story can potentially delve deeper into how media interacts with a person’s emotions and how their distorted online image can lead to real-life psychological turmoil, as seen earlier in season 1.
Marissa and Jenny are not the only characters to step into gray territories by the final moments of the show. Detective Alcaras himself is still dealing with the moral and ethical aftereffects of his acts of corruption, and that is bound to impact how he conducts his police work. With the closing of Carrie’s case, the show has the opportunity to bring some undivided focus onto the officer and his psyche, and a potential sequel could make ample room for that. The same holds true for Brian and Lia, who are yet to truly process the deaths of their loved ones. While their relationship with Marissa is unlikely to be strained, Lia’s inkling that Marissa was involved in her brother’s murder can create conflict down the road. As such, many more iterations of domestic turbulence can be expected in a potential continuation of the story, with or without a new mystery providing the groundwork.
Read More: Is All Her Fault Based on a True Story?
