Brent Holloway Murder: What Happened to Adam Cooper?

In the early hours of October 16, 1995, first responders in Teller County, Colorado, rushed to a cabin near the unincorporated district of Divide after receiving reports of it being engulfed in flames. They managed to control the blaze without issue, only for another tragedy to strike mere hours later as deputy Brent Andrew Holloway was killed while surveilling the same burned property. Thankfully, with the help of candid statements and witness reports, it didn’t take long for authorities to bring this matter to a close. ID’s ‘Homicide Hunter: Lt. Joe Kenda: Manifesto’ explores the case in detail and also features interviews with the officials involved in the investigation and Brent’s loved ones.

Brent Holloway Was Leading a Fulfilling Personal and Professional Life in the Mid-1990s

Born on July 12, 1968, Brent Andrew Holloway was a proud native of Marion County, Ohio, where he grew up in a supportive home alongside incredibly devoted parents and kind, loving siblings. That’s also where he first came across the woman he believed to be the love of his life, Kelly Kirkpatrick, as they were both members of the class of 1987 at Cardington-Lincoln High School. The high school sweethearts blissfully tied the knot in August 1989, by which point he was a passionate amateur artist with dreams of being in law enforcement, while she attended nursing school.

It was during a road trip vacation to Colorado in 1990 that both Kelly and Brent fell in love with the local mountains, driving them to pack their bags and relocate less than a year later. They chose to settle down in the small town of Divide, Teller County, after which he enrolled in the police training academy while his wife held the fort by securing a good nursing job. He subsequently volunteered as a Reserve Officer for the Teller County Sheriff’s Department, served as a Warden at Teller Jail, and did patrol for a year before becoming a Deputy in 1994.

Brent Holloway Was Fatally Shot in the Head in the Line of Duty

Brent was thus just a 2-year full-time veteran in law enforcement when he got the call about the cabin fire at 416 Cochetopa, west of Divide, at roughly 1/1:30 am on October 16, 1995. According to records, it didn’t take long for him, other officials, or firefighters to arrive and calm things down, but the 27-year-old deputy was still requested to guard the scene for the night. Those in charge suspected the blaze was no accident, so they asked for surveillance to protect all the evidence until fire investigators could properly begin their work in the clear morning light.

Brent alone was put on detail outside the secluded property at the end of 8 miles of dirt road, and as protocol, he checked in with dispatch every hour until 6 am under his call sign of K19. However, everything changed when he didn’t touch base for a couple of hours, resulting in an appeal to any nearby officer to conduct a welfare check on the deputy who was supposed to be on duty. That’s when the young man was found slumped over the steering wheel of his patrol car – his autopsy later confirmed he was shot in the back/side of his head at close range with a 20-gauge shotgun.

Initial Investigations Into Brent Holloway’s Murder Led Nowhere

Since the Teller County Sheriff’s Office is a rather small department and almost everyone there was arguably too close to the matter, as they knew Brent, they reached out to nearby agencies for help. Detectives from different cities/counties didn’t hesitate to say yes, leading to an extensive investigation, while fire officials also conducted their own inquiries into the cabin. One of the first things the former noted was that the victim’s city-issued gun was missing from his person and his vehicle, yet it also wasn’t the murder weapon because his wound was simply too large.

The fact that it appeared as if Brett didn’t even see his assailant coming, owing to the way he was slumped over his steering wheel and how his window was already open, also raised concerns. That’s when officials hypothesized the alleged arson and murder were likely related, with the individual/s responsible crossing all lines in fear of getting caught. They suspected the alleged assailant behind the fire returned to the scene in hopes of covering their tracks, only to see the deputy, worry they themselves were noticed too, and take his life.

So, while some detectives canvassed the area, others spoke to the fire investigator to ask whether the blaze was accidental or not – it was ascertained that it indeed wasn’t. The cabin’s owner was subsequently contacted and questioned on suspicion of setting his own place on fire for insurance fraud, only to learn the property wasn’t even insured. Rumors that the victim had some beef with volunteer firefighter Walt Mercer over the approach in a prior case were also quashed soon thereafter, with Kelly asserting they were actually friends.

Brent Holloway’s Assailant Turned Out to be an Ex-Convict Recently Out of Prison

It was hours later that a big break came through after a local reported an abandoned car in the Cochetopa area, not far from where the arson was committed and where Brett was found dead. The vehicle was formally registered to a local Teller County construction worker named Matthew Sherwood, but he had also reported it stolen around 12 days prior. Officials decided to question him at his home anyway, where he revealed he hadn’t been 100% forthcoming in his initial theft report because he believed his roommate had taken it to California.

Matthew told investigators he first met Adam Whitney Cooper through work before starting to live with him a few months prior, but he hadn’t seen the 27-year-old, his keys, or his car for almost 2 weeks. He claimed he woke up one morning to find all of them missing, so he filed a cursory report despite feeling he knew exactly who was responsible and why due to a conversation the weekend before. He alleged that Adam seemed to be spiraling because he’d suddenly asked him to drop everything and go to California with him to start anew, to which he said no, since he had his own responsibilities.

Matthew also indicated to detectives that Adam appeared really angry at his response, only to completely vanish for the ensuing week, despite his own ailing yet loving mother living nearby. The mother revealed he’d had his fair share of run-ins with the law over the years, mostly for robberies, theft, and related charges, for which he even served 5 years in prison before being paroled in 1992. She claimed the 28-year-old was indeed spiraling recently, stressed from his criminal history, her chronic illness, and her current diagnosis of cancer, for the treatment of which she reportedly had no money.

Adam Cooper Chose to Die by Suicide Rather Than Face the Legal Consequences of His Alleged Actions

During Adam’s mother’s interview with detectives, she candidly also told them that while she hadn’t physically seen her son in a while, he had written her a rather eerie letter almost two weeks prior. In it, he expressed anger over his stepfather not paying her the court-ordered alimony she was awarded, stating it could fund her treatment and adding he would do anything to make it happen. He also indicated he was furious at law enforcement for not forcing his stepfather to fulfill his obligations, making detectives really concerned about his overall mental state and what he could do in his rage.

Investigators decided to search the forest around the abandoned car on October 17, believing Adam was likely still in the area and hiding. That’s when one search team found 4 Molotov cocktails hidden near a tree, while another heard from the owner of a nearby property they initially couldn’t canvass. During a quick check, it became clear that someone had recently been there, as clothes and food were strewn about, but the owner claimed no one in her family had been there for over a month. The lead officer then heard a sound from the upper floor of the cabin, making it clear the person was still there. A team subsequently came up with a plan to confront the intruder under the impression it was Adam Cooper, but they heard a gunshot just as they were about to break into the one locked door in the house.

The 28-year-old had used Brett’s service weapon to die by suicide. He died at the scene from a self-inflicted gunshot wound to his mouth. On the side table was a police scanner he had also stolen from Matthew, as well as a check made out to “one dead police officer,” and by the door was the shotgun used to kill Brett. Also in the room was a notebook, which turned out to be his journal, 14 pages of which were full of his plans, his regret, and his suicidal ideations. It detailed how he set fire to the cabin in hopes of luring police officers he planned to kill, but he backed out when firefighters also arrived at the scene. The manifesto further included his confession that he saw an open opportunity when he noticed Brett on duty and followed through, only to be riddled with guilt and regret in the hours that followed. In the end, the case closed with one burned house, 2 dead individuals, and no legal proceedings.

Read More: Where is Alex Cooper Now? Update on the Conversion Therapy Survivor

SPONSORED LINKS