Shivangi Sinha
Hulu’s ‘Are You My First?’ is a reality dating series that brings together singles who have never experienced physical intimacy and gives them a chance to find the person they would want to be their first. In the first season, Brooklyn Benson and Layne Gwartney quickly found each other and grew closer in each episode. They had joined the season at different stages, but things fell in sync for them, and they admitted that no one had ever made them feel so special. Their energy and chemistry made them one of the most adorable couples to emerge from the season.
Brooklyn and Layne Got Comfortable With Each Other From the Get-Go
Brooklyn Benson’s arrival on the season brought a wave of drama. Both Andrew and Noah, who were already exploring their own connections, immediately showed interest in her and even chose her as their potential match. However, Brooklyn didn’t feel a spark with either of them, leaving her without a strong connection going into her first elimination round. Though it made her especially vulnerable, instead of being sent home, she was given a second chance to find love. Not long after, Layne Gwartney entered the villa, and from the very beginning, his attention was solely on Brooklyn. He singled her out for a one-on-one conversation, quickly followed by asking her on a date.
Brooklyn instantly felt at ease with him and later admitted that comfort was the most important quality she was looking for in a partner. Their connection deepened quickly, culminating in their first kiss, which left Brooklyn amazed that she had finally found someone she was ready to move forward with. As the competition progressed, Brooklyn and Layne became inseparable. Heading into the finals, they chose to share a bedroom, which became a turning point in their relationship. This step allowed them to not only explore their physical intimacy but also open up emotionally, breaking down barriers that had previously held them back. So, when the time came to decide their future, neither hesitated. The couple confidently declared that they wanted to continue dating and pursue their relationship beyond the show.
Brooklyn and Layne Have Most Likely Ended Their Relationship
On reality TV, romance often blossoms quickly because contestants are isolated and focused only on building connections. However, translating that relationship into the real world is far more challenging. For Brooklyn Benson and Layne Gwartney, distance immediately became a major obstacle. Brooklyn is based in Los Angeles, California, while Layne lives in Hammon, Oklahoma. These are two very different worlds, both geographically and culturally. Maintaining a relationship across that divide requires consistent effort and communication, and it appears the couple struggled to bridge the gap.
After filming wrapped, there has been little to no public acknowledgment of their status. Neither of them has shared updates, photos, or posts suggesting that they continued their relationship beyond the season. They don’t seem to engage with one another socially as well, which strongly indicates that they may have quietly parted ways. Although their connection on the show seemed genuine and strong, the lack of any follow-up confirms that reality set in once filming ended. Distance, lifestyle differences, and the challenges of sustaining a relationship outside a controlled environment likely played their roles. While they were memorable as a couple during the series, it seems their romance did not carry forward in real life. Most signs suggest that Brooklyn and Layne have ended their relationship since leaving the show.
Brooklyn is a Dance Teacher and Model, While Layne is Working as a Pilot
Since her appearance on the season, Brooklyn Benson has continued to thrive in her professional life. Based in Los Angeles, she works as a dance teacher while also pursuing opportunities as a model. Her portfolio has grown steadily, with recent collaborations including a campaign with Mattel’s iconic Barbie brand and catalog work for Jeffree Star Cosmetics. Brooklyn has also made notable on-screen appearances, including her role as a Laker Girl in HBO’s acclaimed series ‘Winning Time: The Rise of the Lakers Dynasty.’
Meanwhile, Layne Gwartney has also carved out a successful career path as a commercial pilot. He has served in the US Army, but this new chapter of his life is also quite enjoyable for him. Like Brooklyn, he shares a strong religious background that has shaped much of his worldview. While his career keeps him constantly traveling, Layne has stayed grounded in his values and faith. Though their relationship appears not to have continued beyond the show, both Brooklyn and Layne have individually built meaningful lives in their respective fields.
Read More: Are Rachael and Michael From Are You My First Still Together?
