Shivangi Sinha
Hulu’s ‘Are You My First?’ centers on the search for a genuine connection, with contestants living together in a villa while exploring romance. In the debut season, Katya Ferrer entered with hopes of finding someone special, and her meeting with Andrew Marino quickly sparked those feelings. Their bond developed naturally, leaving Katya with little doubt that things were moving in the right direction. However, when new contestants joined the villa, she began to worry that her promising future with Andrew could suddenly be put at risk.
Katya and Andrew Were Going Strong Until He Went on a Date With Brooklyn
Katya Ferrer entered the season with her focus set firmly on Andrew Marino. From the very first day, she made it clear through both her actions and conversations that he was the only one she truly wanted to pursue. This devotion, however, had its drawbacks. By choosing not to spend much time engaging with the other male contestants, Katya inadvertently placed herself in a vulnerable position. When the first round of eliminations arrived, several men nominated her on the grounds that she had shown little interest in getting to know them. For a moment, her journey seemed like it would end abruptly, but thanks to a deciding vote, Katya was spared, and she got another chance to strengthen her connection with Andrew.
Afterward, Andrew reassured her that he was interested in building something meaningful and long-term, and Katya trusted his words completely. Their connection seemed secure until a twist shifted the dynamics. With the arrival of new contestant Brooklyn Benson, Andrew’s resolve was suddenly tested. He immediately struck up a conversation with her, and when Brooklyn chose him for a date, he eagerly accepted. The pair spent time together on a yacht, and when he returned, his energy toward Katya felt noticeably different. Confused and hurt, she confronted him directly, asking whether his feelings had changed. He admitted he still wanted to talk to her, but also wanted to explore things with Brooklyn. The uncertainty left her feeling cornered, and ultimately, she was forced to make a choice about her future in the villa.
Katya and Andrew Are No Longer in a Romantic Relationship
For Katya, Andrew’s decision during their time on the season spoke volumes. She made it clear that if she was going to invest in someone and take meaningful steps forward, she needed to feel like their top choice, not an afterthought. When she realized Andrew’s attention was divided, she chose not to wait around and instead walked away, firmly deciding against pursuing him. Though the choice hurt, she carried herself with dignity and said she would rather be single than settle for uncertainty.
In the months since, Katya has moved past the disappointment and even maintained a cordial friendship with Andrew. While they may not be as close as they were in the villa, they are not openly hostile either. Sharing the unique experience of being reality TV love interests has kept some connection intact, but a romantic future between them post the conclusion of their journey on ‘ Are You My First?’ appears highly unlikely.
Katya is a Passionate Theater Artist, While Andrew is Running His Own Business
Katya Ferrer has leaned into her passion for the arts. As a theatre actor, she continues to pursue her creative career while nurturing her adventurous spirit. Though she loves camping and rugged exploration, she finds just as much joy in immersing herself in art, history, and culture. Based in Los Angeles, California, and New York City, she stays grounded through her close connection with family while also making time for new experiences and explorations.
Andrew Marino, on the other hand, has continued to focus on building his professional and personal life. An entrepreneur at heart, he is the founder of Royal Guard, which is a personal hygiene care brand. Outside of work, he maintains a strong commitment to fitness and is often seen giving time to his health and wellness. Traveling also remains an important part of his lifestyle, and it has allowed him to broaden his horizons and recharge. Family is central to him, and he is especially close to his nephew.
Read More: Did Jade and Ty End Up Together or Break Up in Are You My First?
