Naman Shrestha
ABC’s ‘Capturing Their Killer: The Girls on the High Bridge’ is a three-part docuseries that chronicles the brutal killings of two teenagers, Liberty “Libby” German and Abigail “Abby” Williams, in Delphi, Indiana, in February 2017. During the 5-year-long investigation, Libby’s family remained patient as the detectives worked hard to bring the perpetrator, Richard Allen, to justice. In the documentary, several members of her family feature and talk about the impact the tragedy had on their lives.
Libby German’s Family Endured Five Years of Grief Before Finding Justice
On December 27, 2002, Carrie and Derrick A. German welcomed Liberty Rose Lynn “Libby” German into the world in Lafayette, Indiana. She grew up alongside four sisters — Kelsi, Hayden, Glenna, and Alexis. Libby also shared a close-knit bond with her grandparents, Mike and Becky Patty. Growing up in Delphi, Indiana, Libby was constantly surrounded by the love and support of her family. When she disappeared alongside her best friend, Abby Williams, on February 13, 2017, her family was deeply concerned about her safety and whereabouts. Their worst nightmare came true when the remains of Libby and Abby were discovered the following day. After waiting for five long years, Libby’s family finally got a sense of closure and justice when Richard Allen was convicted and sentenced for killing the two teenagers.
Mike and Becky Patty Keep Libby’s Memories Alive in Their Hearts
In March 2025, on behalf of the family of Libby German, Mike Patty expressed his opinion on the appeal that was filed by Richard Allen. He gave the following statement to WTHR: “While we realize that filing an appeal is a part of his judicial rights, we wish he would not pursue this course of action and own up to his numerous confessions and accept the conviction he received after a trial of his peers. His actions continue hurting my family with the continued filings, along with leaks of evidence and information. We have faith in the Lord and our justice system that our girls will finally get to rest in peace. The girls deserve better than these recent actions that have been done.” Much like her better half, Becky Patty also continues to hold Libby’s memories close to her heart and remembers her at every given opportunity.
Carrie is Still Close With Her Daughters, While Derrick is Leading a Private Life
Hailing from Royal Center, Indiana, Carrie Timmons currently resides in Harrodsburg, Kentucky. After studying Psychology from Midway University, she worked at two companies for a short while in 2017: DropCom and Trane. She then worked as an RSP/Stow/Pick/ICQA at Amazon Fulfillment Center LEX1 for four years until 2021. For the following three years or so, Carrie was a bartender at O’Charley’s Restaurant + Bar, Agave & Rye Lexington Square, and Versailles Brewing Company. As of today, she has been employed at Machal Tax Service since January 2025. In her free time, Carrie likes to enjoy the company of nature and her daughters, whom she considers the apples of her eye. As for Derrick, he also misses his late daughter, Libby, every once in a while. However, not much is known about his life as he prefers to stay away from the spotlight.
Kelsi Siebert is a Mother of Two Today, While Hayden Timmons is Seemingly a Content Creator
Kelsi German Siebert was one of Libby German’s family members who kept the pressure on the authorities to solve the case and bring the perpetrator to justice. Meanwhile, she pursued Communication and Media Studies at Ball State University before attending Purdue University, where she majored in Psychology. Kickstarting her professional career as a Shift Lead at Dairy Queen, she also served as the Third Key at Claire’s and a Shift Lead at The Blue Moose. Between 2019 and 2021, she worked at Kohl’s as a Customer Service Representative. Kelsi has also worked as a Receptionist at Changes Salon. Currently, the Lafayette, Indiana, resident is an Independent Consultant.
On the personal front, Kelsi got married to the love of her life, Kaleb Siebert, on June 25, 2022. Just a couple of months later, the couple entered parenthood as they welcomed their daughter, Ellie, into the world. Kelsi became a mother for the second time in March 2025 as she gave birth to their second daughter, Avery Ann. As for Libby’s other sister, Hayden Timmons, she resides in Lexington, Kentucky, where she lives with her furry little friend named Vincent Van Gough. From what we can tell, she is a highly active creator on social media accounts.
Read More: Brad Holder: Where is the Cleared Delphi Suspect Now?
