Shivangi Sinha
Lifetime’s ‘The Body in the Locker’ unfolds like a slow-burning puzzle with each scene peeling back another layer of a long-buried secret. The story centers on Amy Robertson, a respected nonprofit CEO whose life turns around after her father’s death. While settling his affairs, she discovers a storage unit he never mentioned. Curious, Amy opens it, only to find the remains of an unidentified woman. The discovery forces her to question everything she thought she knew about her father and whether he might have been involved in something far darker than she ever imagined. Directed by Sean Cisterna, the film uses its intriguing premise to spark deeper questions about trust and the hidden lives of those closest to us.
The Body in the Locker is Seemingly Inspired by a Decades-Old Real-Life Case
The film is not drawn from any single true story or documented criminal case. Instead, it feels shaped by the kind of real-world crimes and unsettling discoveries that often surface in news headlines. Rather than tracing one specific event, the writers appear to have borrowed from the broader landscape of cases involving secret storage units and long-buried remains. By pulling together familiar elements from the world around us, they crafted a narrative that reflects the patterns and possibilities of actual investigations without tying itself to one real incident.
One real-life case that the film might echo is the long-unsolved mystery surrounding Joseph Mulvaney, who disappeared in 1963 and was later linked to skeletal remains found in 1992. The key figures include Joseph Mulvaney himself, his nephew John David Morris, and his granddaughter Shelley Statler, who ultimately identified his bones via DNA testing in 2017. Investigators discovered his skeleton inside a footlocker stored in a shed in Thermopolis, Wyoming, along with a grocery bag tied to Iowa. The trunk had reportedly been transported there by Morris, though the exact circumstances remain unclear. The case has never led to a prosecution, but its elements mirror the kind of secret-keeping at the heart of this movie’s plot.
The Movie Evokes the Raw Emotions of Loss and Discovery
Another case that mirrors the film’s premise of discovering hidden remains in a storage unit and solving a mystery is as follows. In October 2022, the body of former Maquon Police Chief Richard Young was discovered in a storage unit across from the home of Marcy Oglesby in Galesburg, Illinois. Autopsy results revealed lethal levels of tetrahydrozoline, the active ingredient in over-the-counter eye drops, confirming poisoning as the cause of death. Witnesses testified that Young had died in October 2021, nearly a year before his body was found. Oglesby, who had been in an on-again, off-again romantic relationship with Young, was found guilty in June 2025 of first-degree murder, attempted murder, and aggravated battery, receiving a 50-year sentence with additional supervised release.
The film appears to draw inspiration from real-life cases and incorporates elements that resonate beyond fiction. For instance, the storyline of a daughter finding out truths about her father after his death, grappling with limited answers, and then seeking justice for someone outside her family is not unheard of. These narratives highlight the resilience of the human spirit and how people cope when faced with a tragedy. By focusing on curiosity and moral conviction, the film is akin to real-world impulses to pursue truth and accountability, even in circumstances where it is not so comfortable. It emphasizes that such acts of courage and discovery are universal reflections of how humans respond to loss and injustice.
Read More: Is Lifetime’s My Husband’s Other Wife Based on a True Story?
