Upamanyu Biswas
‘Murder at the Lighthouse‘ tells a harrowing thriller story through the eyes of Jess, a woman struggling to escape the clutches of her abusive ex-partner. Fearing for her life, Jess hires a fishing boat captain to help her cross Lake Superior to start a new life in Canada. However, things get complicated when an accident jeopardizes her travel, leaving her stranded on a distant shore. Subsequently, she is rescued by a reclusive lighthouse keeper who nurses her back to health. Although everything seems perfect on the surface, Jess soon realizes that something sinister is afoot in the lighthouse, making her wonder if she is caught in another web of danger. Helmed by Eric D. Howell, the Lifetime movie touches upon a number of realistic themes, such as isolation, abuse, crime, resilience, and survival, which help elevate the narrative.
Murder at the Lighthouse Dives Into the Dangers of Not Confronting One’s Problem
‘Murder at the Lighthouse’ is the brainchild of Shawn Riopelle, who weaved a fictional tale yet focused on some prevalent societal issues. The film embodies the saying “Out of the frying pan into the fire” through a gripping survival story centered on an abuse victim, Jess. After being tormented by her former lover, Jess decides to seek a better life elsewhere by going into hiding, only to encounter something even worse at a remote lighthouse. It metaphorizes the idea that running away from a problem only makes it much bigger and more dangerous to confront later. Although driven by a positive view, Jess is seduced by an alternative means to survive and gets trapped in a bad situation at the lighthouse. Subsequently, she is forced into facing her fears and dealing with her abusive past without looking to escape.
Although the stories differ entirely, the thriller movie ‘Sleeping with the Enemy’ shares a similar premise to ‘Murder at the Lighthouse.’ Based on the eponymous novel by Nancy Price, the Joseph Ruben directorial centers on a woman named Laura Burney who fakes her own death to escape the controlling grip of her abusive husband, Martin. She then moves from her Cape Cod home to Cedar Falls, Iowa, taking on a new identity to keep herself hidden from Martin. However, her new peaceful existence is upended when she realizes that her husband is still after her and itching to turn her life into a living hell. In both movies, there is an emphasis on the idea of hiding from an abusive past and seeking a better life elsewhere. Unfortunately, the two protagonists end up attracting even more significant threats in their quest to run away from something dark and sinister.
Murder at the Lighthouse Poses Critical Questions About Domestic Abuse
There have been plenty of real-life cases in the past of female abuse victims fleeing from their aggressor in the hope of survival. For instance, Lobna Yakout, an alleged victim of abuse, escaped a relationship with her former husband, Karim Selim, who was later found to be a serial killer. Yakout alleged to have been abused and nearly killed by Selim on numerous occasions until she was able to break the marriage in 2020. Reports emerged later that Selim was behind the torture, sexual abuse, and murder of three women between November 2023 and May 2024. It puts into perspective the slim margins of survival involved in abuse cases and how they can turn into messy and complicated affairs that only leave behind trauma. Something similar happens to Jess in ‘Murder at the Lighthouse.’
While the specific events and characters are wholly original in the Lifetime movie, the contextual details closely resemble real-life cases like Yakout’s. The film raises a number of thought-provoking questions about women’s safety and the nature of predatory behavior. In her desperation to escape one monster, Jess lands in the lap of another. Unfortunately, this is the case for several people around the world. As a result, the themes explored within the narrative are true to life, even if the story is drawn from the writer’s imagination. It touches upon the tragic reality of most domestic households and the unspoken perils visited upon individuals within the confines of their homes and by people they trust. It may be fictional in its depiction and exaggerated at points, but the points raised are still pertinent.
Read More: Murder at the Lighthouse Review
