The Better Sister Season 2: Will it Happen?

While Prime Video’s ‘The Better Sister‘ concludes on a seemingly definitive note at the end of its inaugural season, the show’s numerous twists and turns make it a perfect candidate for further exploration down the line. With a strong sibling connection at the heart of the narrative, the project has the legs to expand into a much broader territory where Chloe and Nicky could tackle more mysteries as they move into the next phase of their relationship. However, it infringes on the neatly written conclusion drafted by the show’s creative team, especially when it comes to handling the interpersonal bonds between our central characters. Still, season 2 could delve into some uncharted areas, particularly when it comes to the show’s addictive blend of complex family dynamics and intricate murder mystery.

The Better Sister Could Be Confined to a Single Season Due to Its Source Material

One of the main reasons why ‘The Better Sister’ may not return for a second season is because the show is essentially an adaptation of Alafair Burke’s eponymous 2019 thriller novel. The book is a standalone story with no planned sequels, suggesting that it was intended as a self-contained project. To that end, if the show’s creators wish to continue the narrative, they must craft an original story from scratch. Additionally, the show’s limited series tag is another indicator that a single-season installation was the primary objective from the beginning. This makes sense when dissecting the ending, especially how the different story beats and character arcs fit into place after going through various ups and downs. It highlights the satisfactory nature of the conclusion, decreasing the likelihood of a season 2 renewal.

Intriguingly, in the author’s note section of ‘The Better Sister,’ Burke stated that her three novels – ‘The Ex,’ ‘The Wife,’ and ‘The Better Sister’ – form a “thematic trilogy of novels that explore the complexity of female relationships and the diverse roles that women play in contemporary society.” Thus, it offers a glimmer of hope that the show’s creative team might find a similar angle in the off-chance they decide to bring back the show for a second season. However, it could lead to some wholesale changes that might lead to other differences from season 1. To that end, it goes back to the earlier argument that the show’s length could be contained to only one season. While this may be frustrating to fans of the series, it allows the show to wrap itself up in a rather poetic manner.

The Better Sister Might Delve Into More Complex Family Themes in Season 2

Although the chances of season 2 are low for limited series projects like ‘The Better Sister,’ the show could reinvent itself in the event of a second installation. For instance, it could embrace the anthology series format, bringing new characters and drama into the mix even though the thematic essence remains the same. In the past, shows like ‘The White Lotus’ and ’13 Reasons Why’ have received multiple season entries despite originally starting off as a single-season project. Like the Prime Video series, the latter is based on a standalone novel, limiting its ability to draw from its source material beyond the first season. However, it continued after receiving critical acclaim and widespread recognition from fans worldwide. Thus, the same could apply to ‘The Better Sister.’

Despite satisfactorily concluding its various plot threads at the end of season 1, the second season of ‘The Better Sister’ could shine a spotlight on Nicky and Chloe’s relationship, especially after their reconciliation in the final moments. The writers could explore the next step in their bond and whether their past differences resurface as they take care of Ethan moving forward. Furthermore, Nicky’s involvement in Adam’s murder is swept under the carpet in the first season. To that end, the truth behind her crime could be an enormous sticking point for a second season, providing the necessary drama and urgency for it to have a similar tension and dread running throughout the narrative. Therefore, there is no end to the story material the show could dive into in case a second season becomes a reality.