Thomas and Angela Strussion Murders: Where is Andrew Griffin Now?

The day of September 21, 2021, began like any other for the residents of Belmont, Ohio. However, tragedy struck when 52-year-old Thomas Steed Strussion, lovingly known as Tom and Tommy, and his 49-year-old wife, Angela Jo Strussion, were killed inside their home. Although officials initially responded to a house fire, it was later determined that foul play was involved. ABC’s ’20/20: Murder on the Menu’ takes a closer look at the details of the double homicide and how investigators identified the killer. Moreover, the episode features interviews with their loved ones and the officials who helped solve the crime.

Thomas and Angela Strussion’s Lives Revolved Around Their Career and Pets

Thomas Steed Strussion, affectionately known as Tom and Tommy, arrived as a bundle of joy in the lives of Thomas and Linda Steed Strussion on November 19, 1968. Born in Bellaire, Ohio, he was known among his family and friends for his kindness. As he grew up, he formed a special bond with his sister, Lisa Balog, and his brother, Chris Strussion. After graduating from high school, Thomas went on to live in multiple states like Nevada, Texas, and Tennessee. He began his professional journey by running a hot dog stand before working at several other restaurants.

Thomas spent another 7 years in Texas, exploring the restaurant business before establishing Salsa Joe’s Tex-Mex Smokehouse with a business partner in Arlington. Eventually, he made his way to Ohio for his father’s advancing age. In June 2020, he opened a Salsa Joe’s Tex-Mex Smokehouse outlet in Belmont, serving as its Lead Cook, Manager, and owner. By May 2021, he expanded the business to Elm Grove, West Virginia. In his personal life, Thomas found his soulmate when he met Angela Jo Strussion.

Angela was born to Eddie J. Cutrer and Jan Berthiaume Butcher on September 3, 1971, in Monroe, Louisiana. Sadly, her parents’ union didn’t work out, and they divorced. Over time, Eddie moved on to marry Ann Cutrer, while Jan found a second chance at love and tied the knot with Ken Butcher. Angela grew up forging a good relationship with her brother, Eddie Joe Cutrer, and stepsisters, Jennifer Carnes and Michele Odena. After completing her education, she took on the role of Director of Campaign and Lead Management for Global Business at First Data Merchant Services Corporation.

Thomas and Angela Died From Gunshot Wounds Before the Fire Started

After Thomas and Angela tied the knot, it didn’t take them long to welcome their two dogs and a cat into their lives. She then began helping her husband run the establishments in Belmont and Elm Grove. On September 21, 2021, officials received multiple 911 calls around 7 am reporting a house fire on Trail’s End Drive in Belmont. When officials arrived at the scene, they discovered that employees of a nearby garage had tried to contact the home’s residents, Thomas and Angela, but received no response.

One of the garage employees, who was a volunteer firefighter, eventually managed to enter the home through an unlocked backyard entrance and pull Angela’s remains from the living room. Upon arrival, authorities brought Thomas outside, but both he and Angela were declared dead. However, once the fire was brought under control, forensic experts became concerned, noting the substantial amount of blood inside the house. Unfortunately, their three pets were also found dead inside the home.

The fire marshals eventually discovered that someone had started, or attempted to start, fires in four different locations inside the house, including the couch and master bedroom. The autopsy revealed that Angela was shot three times in the head, while Thomas was shot once in his upper right shoulder area and twice in the head. However, experts didn’t find any soot inside their lungs, indicating that they had died before the fire began. The pair’s cause of death was determined to be multiple gunshot wounds.

Multiple Cellphone Records Led Investigators to Focus on the Killer

When fire marshals initially examined the crime scene, they determined that someone had deliberately attempted to set the house on fire, possibly to destroy evidence. As the investigation continued, they pursued multiple leads, including two individuals who had allegedly been extorting Thomas for money. However, according to reports, both were eventually ruled out as suspects. Authorities then learned that Andrew had previously become a business partner with the couple, sharing stakes in the Salsa Joe’s Elm Grove branch on March 17, 2021. Within the next four months, he invested around $106,000 in Thomas and Angela’s venture, AJS Holdings.

According to court records, Andrew and Thomas met on August 23, and during the meeting, the former informed the latter that he no longer wanted to be part of the venture because it was not profitable. Thomas and Angela then removed Andrew’s name from the AJS Holding bank account the following day. Investigative reports suggest that when officials checked the couple’s business partner’s cellphone records, it suggested that the device was not in Ohio at the time of the murder. Things changed in 2023, when digital forensic experts reviewed those records closely. They found an unfamiliar number associated with a burner phone near Thomas and Angela’s residence around the time of the crime.

Further investigative records suggest that, as officials dug deeper, they found the burner phone was active from September 19 through the morning of September 21. Additionally, Andrew’s regular phone had very little activity from around September 19 to the afternoon of September 21. They traced the burner phone to a Walmart where it was purchased, along with a portable charger. A breakthrough came when Andrew’s former wife, Stacey Griffin, located a similar charger belonging to him and handed it to the officials. On February 18, 2025, he was arrested in Hawaii before being extradited to Ohio in March. Andrew was charged with 12 counts of aggravated murder and one count each of aggravated arson and aggravated burglary.

Andrew Griffin is Awaiting His Sentencing at a County Jail in Ohio Today

The jury trial of Andrew began in October 2026, during which the prosecution introduced multiple witnesses and evidence, including the cellphone records. They argued that he planned the double homicide, allegedly due to the financial dispute with Thomas. They also focused on Andrew’s friend, Brett Cole, who was connected after a cellphone found in Andrew’s car was traced back to him. By the time of the trial, Brett was serving a life sentence in federal prison and had been granted immunity in exchange for his cooperation with the prosecution. In his testimony, he said that Andrew killed Thomas and Angela. He also testified that Andrew had handed Brett his regular phone before going to Ohio in an attempt to create an alibi.

In another testimony, Brett’s grandfather, Arthur Cole, claimed that he overheard Andrew telling someone on the phone that he was going to retrieve his money and had killed two people. On the other hand, the defense contended that there was insufficient evidence pointing to the defendant and questioned the credibility of the witnesses, particularly Brett. On November 4, 2026, Andrew was found guilty on two counts, each for aggravated murder of Thomas and Angela. He was also convicted of aggravated arson and trespassing. His sentencing date is currently scheduled for December 1, 2026, and the prosecution revealed that they were not seeking the death penalty. As of writing, Andrew is being held at the Belmont County Jail in Saint Clairsville, Ohio, where he awaits his sentencing hearing.

Read More: Susan Lane Murder: Where is Michel Fournier Now?

SPONSORED LINKS