Naman Shrestha
Based on Suzi Weinert’s ‘Garage Sale Mystery’ book series, Hallmark’s ‘Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder Takes the Stage’ is a murder-mystery drama movie directed by Paula Elle. The narrative revolves around a new, mysterious case in which Jennifer Shannon is expected to make the most of her investigative skills and uncover the truth. While Jennifer and her famous true-crime book club are in the middle of reenacting the infamous Lizzie Borden case, one of the book club members is killed under mysterious circumstances. Now, she must take matters into her own hands and follow a trail of evidence that could put her and other members in danger. The suspenseful tale unfolds primarily at the property where the book club meeting is held and where the murder takes place, serving as an additional character.
Where Was Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder Takes the Stage Filmed?
‘Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder Takes the Stage’ was filmed in its entirety in British Columbia, particularly in Vancouver. According to reports, principal photography for the Hallmark production commenced in mid-June 2026 under the working title ‘Garage Sale Mystery: She Took an Axe’ and wrapped up after more than two weeks in the first week of July of the same year. One of the cast members, Lauren Akemi Bradley, took to social media after the conclusion of the shoot to share her experience bringing the movie to life. She wrote, “Wrap day. Spent the last three weeks with an amazing crew and a hilarious and incredibly talented cast. Days filled with deep belly laughs, huge dresses that barely fit in our trailers, and a whole lot of movie magic. My heart is very full.”
Vancouver, British Columbia
All the pivotal sequences for ‘Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder Takes the Stage’ were lensed in and around the city of Vancouver, in British Columbia’s Lower Mainland. From what we can tell, the cast and crew took over a waterside property, which stands in for the venue where the book club meeting takes place. Its exteriors and interiors feature in many important scenes throughout the narrative. The production team set up cameras and other equipment in multiple rooms to tape key indoor scenes involving Jennifer and the murder suspects. Other notable movies and TV shows filmed in Vancouver include ‘Along Came a Spider,’ ‘Longlegs,’ ‘Bad Times at the El Royale,’ ‘The Unforgivable,’ ‘The Killing,’ ‘High Potential,’ and ‘Prison Break.’
Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder Takes the Stage Cast Details
Lori Loughlin and Sarah Strange lead the cast of ‘Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder Takes the Stage’ through their compelling performances, bringing the enthralling narrative to life. The former is a New York City native with multiple producing credits on projects such as ‘Homegrown Christmas,’ ‘Fall Into Winter,’ ‘Blessings of Christmas,’ and ‘When Calls the Heart.’ She is also the creative mind behind ‘Summerland.’ As for Sarah, she lent her voice to dubbing numerous movies and episodes of the Japanese anime ‘Ranma ½’ in the 1990s. Both have collaborated on other movies in the ‘Garage Sale Mystery’ film series.
Lori Loughlin as Jennifer Shannon
Lori Loughlin dons the garb of Jennifer Shannon, the detective who tries to solve the murder case, in the Hallmark production. Widely known for her roles in shows like ‘When Calls the Heart’ as Abigail Stanton, ‘Full House’ as Becky, and ‘Summerland’ as Ava Gregory, Lori also features in ‘The New Kids’ as Abby, ‘Northpole: Open for Christmas’ as Mackenzie, and ‘Every Christmas Has a Story’ as Kate Harper.
Sarah Strange as Dani
In ‘Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder Takes the Stage,’ Sarah Strange essays the role of Dani. You might find her face familiar because she portrays Jill Langston in ‘ReGenesis,’ Helen in ‘Da Vinci’s Inquest,’ Annette Bishop in ‘The L Word,’ and Jane in ‘White Noise.’ Her film credits include the likes of ‘Must Love Christmas,’ ‘Christmas at Dollywood,’ ‘A Summer Romance,’ and ‘Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Death at the Diner.’
The whodunnit film also features a bunch of other talented actors in supporting roles, including Steve Bacic as Jason, Lauren Akemi Bradley as Helen, Liza Huget as Carol, John Murphy as Milton, and Kevin O’Grady as Frank.
Read More: Haunted Harmony Mysteries Prelude to a Wedding: Filming Locations and Cast Details
